Friday, February 5, 2010

Risks of Genetic Engineering

What are the risks of genetic engineering? The revolution that genetic engineering caused was profound. There was initially great concern about genetic engineering. The concerns centered on several aspects of this work. First, the bacteria used in these experiments were E. coli. This bacterium commonly lives on our intestines. People were worried about what will happen if this laboratory organism got out into our gut. Could the bacteria lead to cancer? This fear led almost to hysteria. Municipalities passed laws banning all genetic engineering work. A very famous scientist arrived to his laboratory one day to find the police out front, saying “you’ve broken our municipal ordinance against doing any gene swapping”. Doom scenarios were all over the place.

In 1975, a conference was held in California which brought together scientists, ethicists, physicians and lawyers to deal with this situation. This was a unique event in the history of science and government relations. The meeting was called by the scientists who were doing the work. They wanted some sort of feedback on what they were doing, because they were worried about the possible risks of genetic engineering.

At this meeting, after several days of heated discussions, they decided to do a moratorium on certain types of experiments. For example, until they knew what they were doing, they weren’t allowed to put cancer genes into bacteria to study them. They imposed extreme safety precautions on all of their types of experiments. Government agencies and institutional boards at research universities were set up to oversee this.

Scientists really asked for this oversight, which is very unusual, because scientists usually are of the type “just let us do our work and leave us alone, we would never harm you”. In this case, scientists were quite worried because this was so profound a change in biological manipulation.

In retrospect, these concerns were overblown, and no dangerous events have really occurred with genetic engineering. In fact, experiments that required severe precautions in 1975 are now done in high-school science labs. This doesn’t mean that we don’t need to constantly monitor this research. If we are dealing with harmful genes we must take extreme precautions.

Be the first to leave a comment

Post a Comment

Copyright © 2010
Template by bloggertheme